Two hours after the announcement that the Lebanon Valley College ice hockey team would be moving from the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) to the American Collegiate Hockey Association (ACHA) on Tuesday, February 23, there was a Facebook group created to “Save LVC Ice Hockey.” The group was created by Krystina Chapman ’12, Samantha Stewart ’13, and Brianna Roman ’13, and is intended to raise awareness of the situation and how it was handled.
Only two and a half weeks after the group was created, it had 1,494 members, including players, students, friends, and fans dissatisfied with the administration’s decision. Although not all students may agree with or care about the administration’s decision, the fact that 1,494 persons disagree with it for a school that only has approximately 1,600 students shows large dissatisfaction and tremendous support for the LVC ice hockey team as a NCAA Division III team.
President MacDonald has released a statement to La Vie Collegienne explaining the College’s decision to move its hockey program to the ACHA, a club league.
Regarding this change, one of the hockey players stated, “It’s like telling the baseball team they cut the program, but they’re going to have a t-ball team.”
According to Scott Biggar’s article “Flying Dutchmen Grounded: After Finding Success in the ECAC Northeast, Lebanon Valley College Struggled in the ECAC West,” the college performed an evaluation of the hockey season after Coach Tim Russel’s resignation in January. In order to do this, the college used a “Success Formula,” which looked at factors such as costs, student-athlete graduation rates, travel requirements, missed class time, and competitiveness.
One of the College’s main points in support of their decision includes the team’s performance over the past six seasons after it was unwillingly moved from the Eastern College Athletic Conference (ECAC) Northeast Ice Hockey League, where the team endured success, to the ECAC West for the 2004-2005 season. Since this time, President MacDonald noticed the team has been unable to offer much competition to other schools, as the team has only a .080 winning percentage since the change.
Regardless of the bad winning percentage, the team obviously has many loyal fans.
Stewart noticed, “This year’s freshman class performed amazingly. The team relied greatly on the young players, and they certainly came through for the team on multiple occasions, and for this reason, we believe the team can only progress from here as the freshmen get more experience.”
ECAC West Correspondent Scott Biggar noticed, “Things were actually looking up for the Flying Dutchmen earlier this season. [They] showed a noticeable increase in competitiveness compared to previous seasons. Several coaches around the ECAC West noted this… and were hopeful that the team was rounding the corner. Even after the resignation of Russel in January, the team played on, including an overtime loss to Neumann and close games against Hobart and Utica. Perhaps more than any other time in the last three years, these eight games showed the resilient character of this team.”
In the last eight games, injured captain Spiros Anastasiadis ’10 filled in to help assistant coach Brendon Herr. Anastasiadis had played five games injured before making the switch to helping coach because of Russel’s resignation.
Reflecting on the events Anastasiadis noted, “I could have played [those games] through my injury, but I was given false hope to help coach and turn things around. So I played my last game without even knowing it, and didn’t even get to skate on my senior day.”
Anastasiadis decided to join track, a sport he had not participated in since his freshman year of high school in ’99, so he could end his athletics experience at LVC on his own terms.
Many of the other hockey players also successfully play other sports on campus, including the reinstated lacrosse team and the golf team. According to Anastasiadis, the reason the players are successful on the other teams is because of coaching.
Anastasiadis added, “[Lacrosse] Coach Hause, [Golf] Coach Sorentino, and [Track] Coach Weidler are incredible examples of good role models… I thank Coach Haus for taking in my teammates and giving them a good experience. I thank Coach Sorentino for doing the same… and always supporting us. And I especially thank Coach Weidler for bringing me into her track family and giving me one last opportunity to be a part of something special… It’s just too bad the administration couldn’t give hockey a chance with a coach who cared as much as those three do about their athletes.”
Shaun Stamm ’12 agreed that coaching was the main problem stating, “Our coach was ill-equipped, poorly qualified in the coaching sense, and was hired over the summer months of school when recruiting was out of the question… The administration did not see only winning a pair of games in the 2007-2008 season as a red flag… When Ted Russell resigned, the real turmoil began. We were left with an assistant coach that was by no means capable of coaching a Division III NCAA hockey team in the best conference in the country.” He also added that when Anastasiadis filled in as coach, he was “more devoted than any of the coaches I’ve experienced at this college.”
Stamm said many of the players plan to transfer to other schools where they may not even play hockey, although almost all of the players chose this school to have the opportunity to play DIII hockey.
Regarding the transferring, Stamm added, “This administration is not only losing a hockey team, but perhaps the most diverse group of individuals that LVC has, 32 players from 16 states/provinces and three countries.” Finally, he added, “I am deeply hurt that I will be departing this school on such a negative note. It will be hard not only leaving friends, professors, and the school, but leaving these 31 guys, who are better off as brothers to me, will surely be the hardest thing I’ll ever have to do.”
Regarding the fact that many of these players will have to reevaluate and change their life plans because of their decision to choose LVC for the chance to play hockey, Greg Krikorian stated, “Students come to school for an education, hockey is part of the experience.”
President MacDonald reported that the change to ACHA is a positive change because the administration is certain the team will be successful. The team will compete as a D-1 team, but the team will probably have to play as a D-1 independent competitor for the first year, where the team may have to play D-2 teams to fill the schedule. President MacDonald also noted that he contacted the presidents of 18 other colleges and universities that have teams in the ECAC East or ECAC Northeast and also the Commissioner in order to see if the team could change to one of these divisions
But, the contacts were in vain, as President MacDonald found, “there is no realistic prospect of LVC being welcomed in either the ECAC East or Northeast.”
Though justified by the administration, the effects of their decision to move the hockey team to the ACHA will impact not only the school, but also the community for years to come. The hockey players have assisted student organizations such as Habitat for Humanity and Colleges Against Cancer and have helped the community through events such as the cleaning of Lebanon Park. LVC is losing not only a hockey team, but a band of brothers devoted to the LVC family and its surrounding community.
Tags: